The shining film vs the shining miniseries stanley kubrick produced and directed the shining, which in the films credits claims to be based on the novel by stephen king though it ought to be inspired by the novel instead, cowriting the screenplay with diane johnson. So many people wonder how much of a difference there is between the film and novel of the shining by stephen king. The shining miniseries written by stephen king often gets a bad rap, especially when compared to the stanley kubrick movie. An essay with video headtoheads this is an adapted and expanded version of a talk i gave on september 21, 2017 at kevin geeks out about stephen king at nitehawk cinema in williamsburg, brooklyn. Tv miniseries\ felt mucho redundant in places and that sometimes affected its credibility. The movie sucked because it strayed heavily from the original plot and the miniseries was fucking awesome because it, for the most part, told the story as per the book.
Before he directed the shining miniseries from kings script, garris brought both the stand and sleepwalkers to the screen. This provocative and fascinating documentary, a crowdpleaser at film festivals around the world last year, showcases some of the elaborate theories about. I really liked the mom in the movie, shelley duvall, and liked that the movie was just as much about her as a mother as it was that jack was going insane. Do either of these scream master of humanizing the supernatural to you. Review of the shining novel, movie, miniseries the books. The death of another character is changed radically in the film. By opting to have your ticket verified for this movie, you are allowing us to check the email address associated with. Ive gone through the novel and film multiples times and comprised this list of changes and similarities between the two versions. Stephen king fans thrilled to the closer to the novel approach that made the shining such a best seller. The shining seems to be the only film hes addressed with such extreme asperity, and with so much analysis and intellectual judgment, and with so little willingness to budge on his opinion. It was directed by stanley kubrick and starred jack nicholson and shelley duvall jack torrance nicholson is a recovering alcoholic writer who takes a job as the winter caretaker for the old and luxurious overlook hotel, which every winter becomes completely snowed in. The film is based on stephen kings 1977 novel of the same name and stars jack nicholson, shelley duvall, scatman crothers, and danny lloyd the films central character is jack torrance nicholson, an aspiring writer and recovering alcoholic who. Although i havent seen it, im told its not the best thing ever.
We learned from the day tour that stephen king had a bad case of writers block, stephen and his wife tabitha visited the stanley hotel on october 30, 1974, they were the only two guest to be staying at the hotel that night. The shining went on to become a bestseller, a stanley kubrick movie, a tv mini series scripted by king, and an indelible reference point in popular culture redrum. Dom cobb is a skilled thief, the absolute best in the dangerous art of extraction, stealing valuable secrets from deep within the subconscious during the dream state, when the mind is at its most vulnerable. The shining stephen king, 1977 is largely considered one of the most frightening novels ever written. Hotel that inspired the shining builds on its eerie.
Differences between the shining book vs movie page 3. Differences between the shining book vs movie page 1. Masseys rotting corpse in the shining is unsettling whether youre reading the book, watching kubricks film, or. Find out where the shining is streaming, if the shining is on netflix, and get news and updates, on decider. Jack nicholson and shelley duvall are brilliant, just perfectly cast, nobody else could ever do justice to jack and wendy torrance, and i dont think anybody should try to again. But if youve read the book and watched the film, its. Btw still like the shining since recently watched it but its never been one of my. Jun 05, 2015 stephen kings the shining is a classic piece of literature and stanley kubricks cinematic version shares the same cult status. The opening of nostalgiaween begins with a stopmotion segment of jack skellington dressed as the nostalgia critic as he runs through a forest and comes across the holiday trees of christmas and halloween while the overture from the gypsy baron by johann strauss, jr. Sadly, kings novels dont always make very good films. Less psychological, this film emphasizes the haunted house aspect of the story.
The movie, the shining, is a cinematic masterpiece directed by stanley kubrick. Oct 27, 2014 i liked the movie, especially the second half, but unlike my book vs. Most fans dont recognize or even remember the 1997 miniseries at this point, with kubricks film casting a strong enough shadow that it remains the definitive visual representation of. On april 27, 1997, the shining miniseries was released to tepid response. Whether developed for television or straighttovideo remember video tapes. Tv has been a favorite home to adaptations of stephen king books and short stories into series, miniseries, and tv movies since 1979 tv series salems lot. Why is the shining book better than the shining movie.
Actors nicholson really put it all out there in the crazy department and i liked it, even if it wasnt how i pictured jack at all in the book. The shining 1997 this smackdown is meant to determine which flick is the better horror movie. The shining full movie information, watch movie online. A third door stands between them with the nostalgia critics face on it. Banality defines the miniseries, in which everything is made smaller, more obvious, and more comprehensible than it was in kings book. Carrie, salems lot amazingly, a tv movie, the shining the film, it another tv movie, stand by me, misery, bag of bones another tv movie. It was also the first full novel i read coverto conver. In 1997, king helmed a madefortv adaptation of the shining which sought to restore his vision of what it ought to be on film. Whether you dislike the 1980 shining because it deviated from the book is largely irrelevant. In the movie the motivation of the ghosts is to possess jack torrance to get him to kill danny. The shining itself the title comes from the line we all shine on in the john lennon song instant karma is the uncanny ability to.
The tv mini series was like too many of kings novels made into movies, confusing, slowmoving and talky. The mini series was a huge mistake except for the scene with the woman in the tub. Kevin geeks out is a monthly series of talks on geeky topics hosted by kevin maher. King famously hated kubricks intellectual approach to the material castigating it as a film by a man who thinks too much and feels too little and, uniquely, managed to wrest the rights to his own work back from. I want to know what happens in a story relatively quickly. The shining director stanley kubrick, 1980 is certainly one of the scariest movies ever made, a classic chiller from one of the great eras in horror movie history. As far as older stephen king adaptions go, these two are my favorites. What the shining miniseries reveals about the kingkubrick. This show has both its ups and its downs, as an adaption of the book, the mini series is fantastic, however the special effects are rather dated now, regardless, i enjoyed the overall experience and. Cobbs rare ability has made him a coveted player in this treacherous new world of corporate espionage, but it has also.
The average tomatometer is the sum of all season scores divided by the number. Jack is an alcoholic and child abuser who has reportedly not had a drink for five months but is anything but a. I wish i was, but it just doesnt hold my interest for long enough. All work and no play makes jack a dull boy or, rather, a homicidal boy in stanley kubricks eerie 1980 adaptation of stephen kings horror novel. After the television miniseries version of the shining ran on abc in 1997, mr. Lets apply his standards to the shining movie and to the shining television miniseries. The shining stylized as stephen kings the shining is a threeepisode horror television miniseries based on the stephen king novel of the same name. A series gets an average tomatometer when at least 50 percent of its seasons have a score. I suppose a case could be made for personal taste, here, but this is like bringing a legally unsound to begin with case all the way to the supreme court and hiring lionel hutz to argue it. Tv series merrygoround of the shining gets another spin this week with the wide release available in theaters and on itunes of room 237.
He starts off with not much personality, which is kind of saved up for later in the story when the house gets in his head and he becomes a clown. King wrote a miniseries version of the shining in 97 in order to more faithfully bring his book to the screen. Much preferred the miniseries and carrie is an all time favorite. It has been parodied in everything from the simpsons to ready player one and became synonymous with kubricks version of the shining related. So i read the book first, it was a bit slow at first but i grew interested in the book because of the depth of the characters and other things, however last week i saw the film, and i hated it. I listened to the audio book of the shining by stephen king in 2010 post here watched the 1980 movie last month post here. Heres every difference between the shining book and the. The shining is a 1980 horror film loosely based on stephen kings novel of the same name.
Stanley kubricks 1980 film the shining is considered a horror. Heres every difference between the shining book and the film. Stanley kubricks 1980 film the shining is considered a horror masterpiece, and even one of the greatest films ever made. Another iconic scene designed to inflict fear into the viewer is the famous shot of blood pouring out of the lift. A recovering alcoholic must wrestle with demons within and without when he and his family move into a haunted hotel as caretakers. But in some ways, his spunky childacting can be seen as a countermeasure to the catatonia of. The movie is not about ghosts but about madness and the energies it sets loose in an isolated situation primed to magnify them. Top 10 differences between the shining book and movie.
The shining my thoughts here in this place, we will introduce the details of the shining full movie information. Review of the shining novel, movie, miniseries the. In the movie just one look from jack nicholson can send chills down the spine the miniseries insists on makeup and cgi to say look, scary movie. Jun 07, 2015 in 1997, king helmed a madefortv adaptation of the shining which sought to restore his vision of what it ought to be on film. Remake faceoff between stanley kubricks 1980 version of the shining and the 1997 miniseries adaptation of the shining, which was directed by mick garris from a script king wrote himself. Dec 11, 2016 the shining film vs the shining mini series stanley kubrick produced and directed the shining, which in the films credits claims to be based on the novel by stephen king though it ought to be inspired by the novel instead, cowriting the screenplay with diane johnson. Oct 31, 20 the shining seems to be the only film hes addressed with such extreme asperity, and with so much analysis and intellectual judgment, and with so little willingness to budge on his opinion. Whats the difference between the shining book and movie.
Check out his first column below, exploring the shining. This essay contains spoilers for both the book and the movie. The eponymous shining plays a smaller role in the film than it does in the nov. Stephen kings the shining is a classic piece of literature and stanley kubricks cinematic version shares the same cult status.
Aug 24, 2019 on april 27, 1997, the shining miniseries was released to tepid response. Whats different between the shining book and movie. The fact remains, this miniseries is very badly produced. The wolf of wall street 20 bluray 400mb dual audio hindi english movie 480p imdb ratings. In defense of the muchmaligned the shining miniseries film. Top ten differences between the shining movie and book. The fact remains, this mini series is very badly produced.
Jan 14, 2019 the shining my thoughts here in this place, we will introduce the details of the shining full movie information. We recently stayed at the stanley hotel in estes park colorado where portions of the stephen king mini series the shining was filmed. The storyplot ultimately, this is the story of one mans descent into madness. The amount of changes is one of the reasons why king hated the film so much. My memory is hazy as its been a number of years since i last read the novel, but i dont remember there being that big a chase sequence in it.
Directed by mick garris from kings teleplay, it is the second adaptation of kings book after a 1980 film by stanley kubrick and was written and produced by king based on his dissatisfaction with kubricks version. In the movie just one look from jack nicholson can send chills down the spine the mini series insists on makeup and cgi to say look, scary movie. That prize, unequivocally, goes to the 1980 version. When you come right down to it, the shining is a haunted. After we finished i was intrigued, so we watched the shining miniseries. In defense of the muchmaligned the shining miniseries. Stanley kubricks the shining was released in 1980, and since has been hailed as one of the greatest horror movies ever made.
Movie, hell be taking a critical look at movie adaptations of horror novels. When watching this mini series, its best to distance this from the iconic kubrick adaption of the shining, as they barely resemble each other. Courtland mead, the little boy who plays danny in the shining mini series, can be annoying at times. Lets not forget the many stephen king miniseries out there that are of equal, if not superior level to many of these films. Jun 26, 2012 the shining was the book which inspired me to write.
In1997, a made for tv miniseries with a television screenplay from stephen king himself hit the small screen in an effort to correct all that kubrick left out. Nov 06, 2019 remake faceoff between stanley kubricks 1980 version of the shining and the 1997 mini series adaptation of the shining, which was directed by mick garris from a script king wrote himself. The conversation when dick explains the shining takes place in his car, and he tests danny to see how strong his shine is. The shining miniseries nostalgia critic channel awesome. Prehaps it would have been a great movie mini series with the jack nickolsonwendy chase scene from 1980and it ended as filmed in 1987 mini series um, this series was released in 1997, not 1987. Dick explains the shining in the kitchen and is not very kind to danny. The shining is a 1980 psychological horror film produced and directed by stanley kubrick and cowritten with novelist diane johnson. While some critics found it to be a creepy suspense in the drawn out 6hour experience, many more found it inferior to kubricks adaptation. Oct 08, 2011 in1997, a made for tv mini series with a television screenplay from stephen king himself hit the small screen in an effort to correct all that kubrick left out. The book, the shining, is a literary masterpiece written by stephen king.
Oct 16, 2017 kevin geeks out is a monthly series of talks on geeky topics hosted by kevin maher. The shining book vs movie and what to watchread first. Even if youve seen the movie 100 times, theres still probably a lot you dont know about what went on behind the scenes. The heart of the matter is that king loves his book, he loves the characters, and he doesnt like the way kubrick went about changing them.
827 279 1399 61 1599 474 1319 963 330 78 724 825 1382 1201 1288 913 881 208 580 196 340 265 263 545 121 1380 119 254 835 1447